Queensland family of teenager killed while tree lopping at church event furious over sentence
Up to date
Lotufou Livingston Sakaria (left) died after he was hit by a falling tree in 2016. (Supplied: Nuufou Foloi Sakaria)
The household of a teenage boy who died whereas tree lopping for a Queensland church say they’re livid it has solely been fined $450,000 over his dying.
- The church was fined $450,000 over ‘s dying
- The boy’s household mentioned the sentence was insufficient
- The utmost penalty for a office well being and security breach is $1.5 million
Lotufou Livingston Sakaria, 14, was tree lopping at a fundraiser for the Samoan Unbiased Seventh Day Adventist Church Queensland (SISDAC) when he was killed by a 12-metre falling tree in Ipswich in 2016.
The church was found guilty of breaching workplace health and safety laws in August and was fined $450,000 on Monday.
The boy’s mom, Nuufou Foloi Sakaria, mentioned the sentence was insufficient.
“To be fined $450,000 — that is nothing,” she mentioned.
“That isn’t sufficient. They obtained loads of revenue from tree lopping.”
The church suspended tree lopping for a yr after the boy’s dying and educated 10 volunteers in security procedures.
However Mrs Sakaria mentioned extra wanted to be completed to enhance security requirements.
“They should cease and do some coaching for everybody,” she mentioned.
The utmost penalty for a office well being and security breach is $1.5 million.
Tree lopping danger ‘plainly foreseeable’
Justice of the Peace Jason Schubert mentioned the sentence wanted to discourage others from failing to adjust to office well being and security necessities.
“The chance to church volunteers, together with youngsters, was plainly foreseeable, as had been the intense penalties of a tree falling on somebody,” Mr Schubert mentioned in a written sentence.
Nuufou Foloi Sakaria said she is furious and heartbroken over the sentence. (ABC News: Anna Hartley)
“Which plainly included the potential dying of a volunteer.
“The church set fundraising targets regarding tree lopping actions for volunteers to acquire [and] the attendance of the volunteers at tree lopping occasions was inspired by the pastor and elders.”
Mr Schubert mentioned he was glad that if the church had complied with its security duties, it was “extremely possible” Lotufou wouldn’t have died.
“I’ve additionally thought-about the necessity to defend the group at giant, together with volunteers, particularly younger and inexperienced youngsters,” he mentioned.
“And different individuals who could possibly be injured or killed from the defendant’s tree lopping actions.”
The church’s standing as a not-for-profit organisation and the monetary compensation it had already offered after the dying was taken in account throughout the sentencing.
The church was ordered to pay prices of $5,843.80 on prime of the $450,000 tremendous, however no conviction was recorded.
Mom felt ‘hopeless’ as son laid lifeless
Through the trial earlier this yr, the Ipswich Magistrates Court docket heard parishioners took half in tree lopping practically each Sunday, with out correct insurance coverage or coaching.
Sakaria Sakaria and Nuufou Foloi Sakaria have been left devastated by their son’s death. (Supplied)
Church leaders known as the dying a tragedy however pleaded not responsible throughout the two-day trial, arguing they weren’t responsible for the boy’s dying.
Mrs Sakaria learn an emotional sufferer influence assertion at a sentence listening to earlier this month.
“The yr 2016 was already a traumatic yr for me and my household as I used to be identified with breast most cancers and had a mastectomy,” she mentioned.
She mentioned the week she returned to work after most cancers remedy her son was killed.
“I felt hopeless as I watched my husband and sons break down in tears, crying and screaming for assist for my boy who lay lifeless on the bottom,” she mentioned.
“We prayed for a miracle however medical doctors informed us there was nothing else they might do and suggested us to change off his life help.
“This tragic loss has had a devastating influence on me, my husband and remaining youngsters’s lives without end.
“No mum or dad ought to should bury their little one.”
Church to enchantment verdict
Defence barrister Jeffrey Hunter QC mentioned whereas the church was remorseful, it didn’t imagine it was responsible for the dying.
“No-one would fail to understand the depths of the household’s grief, least of all of the church,” Mr Hunter mentioned.
“It is vital to not confuse the church’s failure to just accept its obligation for what occurred [with] ethical blame.”
Pastor Jonathan Siofele from SISDAC declined to remark.
The church has filed an enchantment in opposition to the decision however a date is but to be set.